Scéalta – The Early Childhood Ireland Blog

< Back to Blog

What the Children Say – SAC

By: DEIRDRE HORGAN

Tuesday 12 May 2020

‘I like to chillax’ and ‘go outside and play’: What children want from school age care and it’s not a Schoolification model.

The whole landscape of children’s participation in Ireland has evolved since our ratification of the UNCRC in the early 1990’s. I have spent the last twenty years teaching, writing about and conducting participatory research with children. Some of this has involved documenting government consultations with children on a range of policy issues. One such issue – school age childcare - is having a moment! In many ways the ‘Cinderella’ of our childcare services, school age childcare (SAC), is an important and growing cohort of the childcare system representing 20.5% or 40, 588 of all children enrolled in childcare in 2018/19 (Pobal, 2019). There has been recent attention and action from government with the publication of the Action Plan on School Age Childcare, the introduction of the National Childcare scheme, the implementation of systems of registration, as well as the publication of Draft National Quality Standards developed by the National Working Group on SAC in the past two years.


So, it is timely to consider the experiences and views of children in all of this. There have been consultations with a range of SAC stakeholders on issues of access, cost, delivery etc., but no voices are more important than those using the service – the children. There is a consensus that inclusion of children’s perspectives improves decision-making, creates better policy and services, and enhances democratic processes. Simply put, children can tell us things that no other stakeholder can – namely what it is like to be a child using a school age childcare service. No adult can give us this particular insight.

 

Myself and colleagues Jacqui O’Riordan, Shirley Martin, and Jane O’Sullivan reported on Consultations with Children on SAC commissioned for the Action Plan on SAC (DYCA, 2017). These consultations were held in eight counties with 81 five to seven year olds and 96 eight to twelve year olds. The aims were to identify what children like and dislike about their current afterschool care arrangements and the places where children would most like to be cared for after school. The methods included a variety of child-centred group and individual activities including ice-breaker games, post-it activities, place mats, timelines, and voting.

 

So what did we find? Unsurprisingly, play dominated. For both cohorts of children involved in the consultations the issue of play, in particular outdoor play, was a priority and by far the most frequently mentioned activity to emerge when asked to design their ideal or imagined after-school care. A home-like environment was preferred by children of all ages with the findings indicating that children want to be able to relax and feel comfortable after school. Relationships with family, extended family, friends, childminders and other carers were noted as being very important to children. Eating and cooking were also identified as important activities for children after-school.

 

Children in group SAC settings mentioned a larger number of issues which they disliked compared to the children in other SAC environments. They expressed a dislike of being in structured environments with rules, of not being treated appropriately for their age along with lack of food choice. Children were critical of being in settings that they felt they had outgrown and of the limited range of activities and equipment available to them in some SAC settings. Examples they gave included seats that were too small for them, inappropriate and broken toys and equipment, being with children who were younger than them, being unable to play outside, and having to follow similar and very predictable patterns of activities. Some also disliked the ways they were treated by some of the staff in these settings. They were critical of staff who they perceived as being ‘bossy’ or ‘not nice’ and who they felt did not listen to them.

 

In a voting exercise with the younger children, homework was the thing they liked least about their SAC experience. While children seemed resigned to the fact that homework had to be done, it was referred to mostly in a negative light as boring and an inconvenience, with children indicating that they like to get homework out of the way. For some older children in group SAC settings, help with homework was identified as a positive factor. While others disliked having to do their homework because they did not get appropriate help or the setting was too loud. Finally, the older children voted for ‘where would you like to be cared for after school?’ from a list identified by themselves. Overwhelmingly the children voted for home as the place they would most like to be cared for after school (57%). This was followed by friends’ houses, relatives, an afterschool club, childminder and crèche.

 

The Programme for Government 2016 and First Five Implementation Plan 2019-2021 commits to support and expand quality after-school care based broadly on utilising existing primary school buildings and other existing facilities. However, children are telling us they want something very different from school age childcare. How can we resolve these tensions? The Action Plan on School Age Childcare notes that if it is not possible to facilitate children’s preference for SAC at home, ‘then the system of SAC must seek to reproduce their preferences in a variety of settings, other than their home’ (DCYA & DES, 2017, p. 62). One measure is attending to the quality of group SAC provision ensuring quality standards in the physical environment, adult/child ratios, the provision of appropriate food and nutrition, access to outdoor play, inclusion, and the health, well-being and protection of the child in all settings used.

 

A detailed consultation on the development of regulations and a quality framework for school-age childcare took place during 2019, and the final report on the consultation is due to be published shortly. I would argue that any such framework must act on the views and concerns of children - on issues such as transitions from school, the physical space, choice in terms of eating (what and when), activities, and homework. SAC services which forefront play and ‘home from home’ environments must become the norm. Let us see!!!


References:

Pobal (2019) 2018/2019 Annual Early Years Sector Profile Report.

 

Bio:

Dr Deirdre Horgan is a Senior Lecturer in Social Policy at the School of Applied Social Studies, University College Cork. She is Deputy Director of the BA Early Years and Childhood Studies at UCC. Deirdre’s research interests include children and young people’s participation, children’s rights and citizenship, child welfare and protection and childhood migration. She has conducted and reported on a number of consultations with children for the DCYA, and other government departments. Deirdre has presented at international conferences and published widely in international peer-reviewed journal in these areas. She is currently co-editing a book on children’s participation with the Children’s Research Network.

0 comments Comments

Leave a Reply

Please Log In to comment:

educarer(1) HR(1) Consent(1) Research Seminar(1) Learning Story Awards(2) Performance Management(1) Scéalta Blog(99) memories(1) Twitter(1) Certificate(1) emotions(2) The Lullaby Book(1) Growing up Outdoors(1) Limerick(1) Liz Kerrins(1) Toby Bears Camping Trip(1) Reggio(1) Sequins(1) Jillian van Turnhout(1) IGL(1) Snack Time(1) UNCRC(2) Children's Research Network(1) Recycle(1) Infectious diseases(1) Margy Whalley(1) Inspired Practice Awards(1) children development(1) Empathy(1) Childhood(1) Irish(1) Our Little Seed(1) Capable(1) Educator - Leader in Practice Award(1) art of the relationship(1) Mantra(1) listening(1) books(4) Obesity(1) outdoor play(6) Penguins(1) LINC Award for Leadership in Inclusion(2) Tuscan Approach(2) Family(1) Department of Children and Youth Affairs(2) Inspections(1) Whole Group(1) Favouritism(1) toddlers(3) Nonverbal(1) Mount Everest(1) Titles(1) pets(1) preschool(4) Exploring(1) dogs(1) Cognitive development(1) EECERA 2016(1) Irish Early Years Research & Practice Seminar 2018(1) Special Needs Assistants(1) Adoption(1) youdoodle(1) St. Patrick's Day(1) Breathing(2) planning(1) Awards(2) Learning Journal(2) Time Out(1) scéalta(32) Reflective Practice(1) Ceremony(1) Visitors(1) Celebrate(1) CPD(1) parents(6) Snakes(1) staying connected(1) New Appointments(1) Degree(1) Thinking(1) Imagination(3) Brain(1) Awards Night(1) keep in touch(1) structure(1) conference(1) Child mental health(1) Jenga(1) Inspirational(2) European Project(1) Professionalisation(5) Visual Impairment(1) collaboration(1) Cork Institute of Technology(1) Exploring and Thinking(1) Body Language(1) environments(1) Motor neuron disease(1) phone apps(1) Iraq(1) Art(6) Buddy Bench(1) Quality(4) Siolta blog(8) Síolta QAP(1) behavioural science(1) AIM(2) Annual Conference 2019(1) imotion(1) early years learning(1) The Jelly King(1) Horizon 2020(1) gender bias(1) Sustainable(1) Santa(2) Summer(1) Infection Control(1) Aldo Fortunati(4) stories(3) Builders(1) Self-regulation(1) Upcycling(1) Sculptures(1) Yoga(1) Document Learning(1) Line-ups(1) Afghanistan(1) Children(4) Wrapping paper(1) early life(1) Supernanny(1) Orla Kenny(1) Mixed age groups(2) learners(1) code of ethics(1) pablo(1) developing motor skills(1) NAEYC(1) Syria(1) GDPR(1) learning bias(1) childcare services(1) documentation(4) Affordability(1) Impact(1) Settling in(4) Self Help Skills(1) Advocacy(1) Behaviour(3) keezy(1) Graduation(1) routine(2) code of professional responsibility(1) General Data Protection Regulation(1) Trigonometry(1) Pen green(1) awards 2020(1) Self-Esteem(1) Maths(5) College(1) annual conference(1) overhear(1) Human Resources(1) movement behaviours(1) TOY Programme(1) Patterns(1) Inter-generational(2) risk assessment(1) Games(1) Rituals(1) dining(1) Vertical grouping(1) Vietnam(1) curriculum(5) emotional environment(2) Relaxation(1) baby room(1) Building Resilience(1) University(1) Malaguzzi(1) Síolta Quality Assurance programme(1) Policy and Implementation Panel(1) School Age Childcare(1) Deirdre Rogers(1) Family wall(1) Book Review(1) Well-Being(9) National Council for Curriculum and Assessment(1) Thank you(1) Treasure(1) relationships(17) Winter(1) MA(1) Minister for Children and Youth Affairs(1) feisty(1) Weather(1) Elders(1) Bereavement(2) Playschool(1) ICBN(1) Meet the Members(1) Together Old and Young Programme(1) Partnership with Families Innovation Award(2) Routines(2) Confident(1) Mental Health(3) Inspired Practice Award(5) Culture(2) Belonging(3) Exercise(1) Mathematicians(1) mushrooms(1) Lego(2) Early Childhood Care and Education(2) Wilenski(1) Japan(1) Autism(4) Eritrea(1) Seas Suas(1) MECPI(1) purpose(1) Laugh(1) Workplace well-being(1) Youtube Series(1) Oireachtas(1) Magnavacchi(1) PIP(1) Maternity Leave(1) journey(1) SPICE Framework(1) Exit interview(1) Gardening(1) Treasure Chest(1) Budget 2019(2) Feeding(1) Gratitude(1) Support(1) Covid19 crisis(1) Study Trip(1) Identity(5) Storytelling(6) Arithmetic(1) Awards 2019(1) linc(1) value(1) Confidence(1) Covid pandemic(1) life long learning(1) Prexit(1) San Miniato(4) Map(1) Buddies(1) Traffic Lights(1) outdoors(3) Sport(1) Inter-generational learning(2) Vivian Gussin Paley(1) Communicating(1) Cork(1) Masterclass(2) Workforce(1) Loss(1) Exclusion(1) Decisions(1) Department of Education and Skills(1) Creative(1) Mark Twain(1) Story(1) Early Childhood Ireland(1) early learning(1) play(34) healthy eating policies(1) Early Learning and Care Centres(1) AsIAm(2) Super Shed Stories(2) worries(1) Snacks(1) Change(1) Children's Rights(3) Fabric(1) social science(1) Community involvement(1) Socioemotional development(1) refugees(1) Fantasy play(1) Engineering(3) Positivity(1) Early Childhood Ireland National Awards(2) Communications(1) Glitter(2) aistear blog(3) Budget 2018(1) Wendy Lee(3) Smiles(1) Engineers Week(2) Interaction(1) Competent(1) Little Buddies(1) Through the looking glass(1) Workplace Relations(3) National Forum for the Enhancement of Teaching and Learning in Higher Education(1) animals(2) iOS(1) Scents(1) Sessional service(1) Frosty the Snowman(1) Wonder(1) Leprechauns(1) Leargas(1) dining experiences(1) Facebook(1) Aistear Siolta in Action(1) Early Years Educators(3) Access and Inclusion Model(2) listen(1) Children and families(1) supportive environments(2) apps for children(1) National Awards 2019(1) CCTV(1) Music(3) GoToMeeting app(1) educating(1) Traditions(2) role playing(1) Role play(1) Easter(1) Inclusion(3) Children's Voice(1) Plants(1) Equality & Inclusion Guidelines Training(1) E.coli(1) Reggio Emilia(1) Employee(1) Iceland(1) under 3's(3) InspireMe.ie(1) National Pyjama Day(1) National Childcare Scheme(1) Awards 2018(3) Maths Week Ireland(1) Policy(2) ERASMUS+(3) maternity health(1) Opportunities(1) DCYA(4) Norway(2) Environment(2) Sweets(1) Funding(1) RTE Investigates(1) play stories(2) Reggio Children Network(1) Budget 2020(1) Craft(1) meals(3) Ariana Pucci(1) risky play(2) Investment(2) Shoes(1) community(5) Emergent Curriculum(1) Annual Conference 2017(2) science week(2) Valentine's Day(3) National Awards 2018(2) Home Corner(1) Research Conference 2019(1) Christmas Creativity(2) Nuturing interactions(1) Kerry(1) Spiders(1) Teamwork(1) food(1) Child Care(1) Nutrition(1) Sleep(1) Grief(1) NCCA(3) friendships(1) development(8) Engagement(1) Digital Devices(1) Death(2) communication(4) Montessori & Early Childhood Professionals Ireland(1) First 5 transitions for children award(1) Staff Motivation(1) Interactions(2) research submissions(1) DES Inspection(1) Reading Time(1) Early Childhood Ireland’s National Early Childhood Research Conference 2019(1) Giraffe(2) Names(1) Technology(3) Online(1) ECEC(2) Engineering Ireland(1) UN(1) Early Learning and Care(1) Leaders in Practice(1) experience(1) Early Years(1) Italy(1) Social Skills(1) Window(1) National Early Childhood Research Conference(1) Pobal(1) Kids Own(1) Queues(1) Montessori(3) Leadership(1) First 5(1) dublin(2) conversations(1) Magic(1) Kilkenny(1) Pobal sector profile(1) christmas(9) Trade Unions(1) preschool settings(1) Dr. Emer Ring(1) UN Sustainable Development Goals(1) curiosity(3) show and tell(1) ears(1) Fee Play(1) Health(2) Celebrations(4) Graduate(1) Light table(1) Book Club(2) blog(29) Valerie Gaynor(1) ECEC Setting(2) Childcare(3) play therapy(1) Playdough(1) ReCreate(2) Albert Einstein(1) Mindfulness(2) man up(1) Party(1) Sustainability(3) Love(2) Time(2) Wesco(1) National Holiday(1) Mud kitchens(1) Event Guide(1) Participation(2) Qualifications(1) primary education(1) Frustrations(1) early childhood educator(2) Stress(2) Academics(1) Sociodramatic play(1) Appreciation(1) Mayo(1) Childcare Barometer 2018(1) Diversity(1) COVID-19(4) early years research(2) Rich Documentation(1) Pre-School Services(1) Performing(1) Intention(1) Anxiety(2) gender stereotype(1) Photographs(1) story time(2) outdoor space(3) Xbox(1) Independence(1) Dance(1) TRAP(1) Research and Professional Learning(1) Growing up in Ireland(3) Maria Montessori(1) family time(1) Scéalta Book Review(1) Running(1) Primary School(2) trust(5) Administrative Burden(1) interacting(2) Digital(1) Flowers(1) Dr Mary O'Kane(1) Maths Week(1) CIT(1) STEM(3) Mo Scéal(1) Learning Stories Award(3) RIE philosphy(1) Interests(1) First 5 strategy(1) Thanks(1) EM Standing(1) Trick or treat(1) Meal time(1) National Bereaved Children's Awareness Week(1) grandchild(1) learning(19) Educator of the Year Award(3) science(3) UD(1) Training(2) Educators(2) Arlene Forster(1) Aistear(118) Halloween(2) Creativity(4) Decision Making(1) Maynooth University(2) Síolta(112) Hand Hygiene(1) education(2) Irish Childhood Bereavement Network(1) risk(2) Learning Stories(9) Magda Gerber(1) Maynooth(1) Recycling(2) opportunity(1) Identity and Belonging(4) Shapes(1) bloom app(1) bonds(1) Laughter(1) Care routines(1) Trade union(1) Aistear Siolta Practice Guide(1) Universal Design(2) budget(1) Arts(1) INTO(1) research(6) babies(7) Learning Story(1) Touch(1) Biting(1) Potential(1) reading(5) continual professional development(1) Plastic(1) Minister Katherine Zappone(1) United Nations(1) Design(1) Learning journals(1) Providing Leadership to the First 5(1) Care-giving routines(1) social media(1) eating(1) Mealtimes(1) Rising to the Challenge(2) ECCE(7) respect(5) Painting(1) Educator Award - Leader in Practice(1) child-centred approach(1) Challenges(1) Blocks(1) Academic Skills(1) Drawing(2) transitions(10)

SIGN UP FOR BLOG UPDATES

SUBSCRIBE
Site maintained and developed by Cloud Nine